When Chris Turner left the club during 2002/03, Newell was the surprise choice to succeed him as Pools manager. Newell had no previous experience and, with Pools 4 points clear at the top of the division, could hardly have wished for a better first opportunity. A roller-coaster season followed as Newell's Pools extended that lead to 14 points only to lose it. Promotion in second place was not enough to see Newell's contract renewed. He went on to enjoy success at Luton Town.